September 09, 2010
Advanced Search
OVERVIEW OF HUMAN RIGHTS & NATIONAL SECURITY
Home > Issues > Human Rights & Anti-Terrorism
Human Rights & National Security PDF Print E-mail

Throughout history, human rights have been compromised and trampled on in wartime.  Following the atrocities of genocide and ethnic cleansing during World War II, the United States led Europe and other Western states in constructing a framework of laws intended to prevent human rights abuses in wartime.  As it faces new threats in the form of terrorism, the U.S. government must ensure that its anti-terror tactics comport with the human rights standards that it has led the world in accepting and implementing.
 
A number of human rights concerns have been raised by the U.S. government’s anti-terrorism policies, including:

  • credible and documented allegations of torture in military and CIA custody,
  • the indefinite detention of terror suspects in Guantanamo Bay,
  • the use of “extraordinary rendition” to outsource torture,
  • the use of secret prisons without access to Red Cross monitors, and
  • the use of military courts with reduced due process protections. 

Throughout this process, one of the government’s primary strategies has been to seek to prevent judicial review of these practices.  Guantanamo Bay was used as a detention center on the theory, since rejected by the Supreme Court, that U.S. courts could not review the practices there because it was located outside the territorial jurisdiction of the United States.  More recently, the government has sought to restrict or eliminate the availability of habeas corpus remedies in terrorism cases.  
 

For more information on these efforts, see:

 

 
Legal Materials by Issue

-Military Trials for U.S. Residents: Al-Marri v. Bush: Our amicus brief arguing that federal courts have jurisdiction to hear Al-Marri's claims even though Al-Marri labeled an "enemy combatant" and was transferred to a military detention facility

-Military Trials for U.S. Residents: Al-Marri v. Bush: Our amicus brief to the Supreme Court, arguing in support of Al-Marri, that U.S. residents are entitled to due process protections, and that they should be tried by civil, not military, courts

-No Immunity for Torture: Criminal Complaint Requesting Investigation and Prosecution of Crimes Against Detainees in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Guantanamo

-No Immunity for Torture: Request for Appointment of an Independent Counsel to Investigate and Prosecute the Crimes Associated with "Extraordinary Renditions"

-No Immunity for Torture: Request for Hearing Before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, In Re the Military Commissions Act of 2006 (United States)

-Protecting Habeas Corpus: Al Odah v. Bush: Amicus brief in support of Al Odah, arguing that the Geneva Conventions apply to all detainees and are judicially enforceable in habeas proceedings, and that Congress's Authorization of the Use of Military Force (AUMF) Al Odah v. USA)

-Protecting Habeas Corpus: Al Odah v. Bush: Amicus brief in support of Al Odah, following the passage of the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005 (DTA), arguing that all detainees have access to habeas corpus to challenge their detention, notwithstanding the "habeas-stripping" provisions of the DTA

-Protecting Habeas Corpus: Al Odah v. Bush: Amicus brief opposing retroactive application of the DTA to cases in which habeas petitions had already been filed, and also charging that the revocation of access to habeas constitutes a violation of the Suspension Clause of the Constitution

-Protecting Habeas Corpus: Complaint Requesting Investigation and Prosecution of Crimes Against Detainees in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Guantanamo.

-Protecting Habeas Corpus: Complaint to U.S. Attorney General Requesting Investigation and Prosecution of Crimes Committed through "Rendition to Torture"

-Protecting Habeas Corpus: Request for Appointment of an Independent Counsel to Investigate and Prosecute the Crimes Associated with "Extraordinary Renditions"

-Rendition to Torture: Abu Ali v. Ashcroft: Our Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus, seeking for the release and return to the U.S. of Abu Ali, a U.S. citizen who had been unlawfully and indefinitely detained, interrogated, and tortured in Saudi Arabia at the United States' behest

-Rendition to Torture: Abu Ali v. Ashcroft: Our supplemental submission to the court , detailing specific acts of torture committed against Abu Ali, as well as evidence of the complicity between the United States and Saudi Arabia

-Rendition to Torture: Abu Ali v. Ashcroft: The court's denial of the U.S. government's motion to dismiss, holding instead that U.S. citizens continue to possess constitutional rights even when held by foreign officials at the direction of the U.S. government

-Rendition to Torture: Complaint to U.S. Attorney General Requesting Investigation and Prosecution of Crimes Against Detainees in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Guantanamo

-Rendition to Torture: Complaint to U.S. Attorney General Requesting Investigation and Prosecution of Crimes Committed through "Rendition to Torture"

-Rendition to Torture: Federal court's decision that diplomatic assurances from receiving states may not be used to justify transfers of individuals who face the risk of being tortured in such states (Khouzam v. Hogan)

-Rendition to Torture: Request for Appointment of an Independent Counsel to Investigate and Prosecute the Crimes Associated with "Extraordinary Renditions"

-Rendition to Torture: Request to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights to Investigate the Immunity and Habeas-Stripping Provisions of the Military Commissions Act

-Validity of Military Commissions: Our amicus brief challenging the retroactive application of the DTA, and the constitutionality of the DTA (Feghoul v. Bush)

-Validity of Military Commissions: Supreme Court decision holding that the Detainee Treatment Act does not apply retroactively to detainees' habeas petititons filed before the DTA was enacted, and that the military commissions violate U.S. and international law (Hamdan v. Rumsfeld)

Home | About Us | Issues | Who We've Helped | Get Involved | News | Calendar | Contact Us | Site Map